Other pages in this series (34)
Editions comparedshare
Historians' comments in revised editions
Share of articles with a historian's comment, original and revised side by side.
20.2%share with comments, Sukjong Supplement and Corrections
Key point
According to NIKH's tags the revisions carry almost no commentary (a single comment in the Revised Seonjo records), compared with the 52 counted by Oh Hang-nyeong. Count '史臣曰' in the text, not the tags, when working on revised editions.
- Formula
- Articles with comments / all articles, per edition
- How to read it
- If a revision changes judgments through commentary, its share should exceed the original's.
- Caveats
- NIKH tagging. The Revised Seonjo records carry only one tagged comment, compared with the 52 counted by Oh Hang-nyeong, so tagging gaps are likely and are noted in the table.
- External check
- Oh Hang-nyeong (2004): 52 comments on 40 persons in the Revised Seonjo records.
- Reliability card
- exactExact count — read straight from the source XML
Oh Hang-nyeong (2004): 52 comments on 40 persons in the Revised Seonjo records.
| Edition | Articles (A) | Articles (B) | B/A | Characters (A) | Characters (B) | B/A | Shared days | Of B's days | Of A's days | Historians' comments A | Historians' comments B |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Veritable Records of King Seonjo → Revised Veritable Records of King Seonjo | 26,716 | 1,874 | 0.070 | 4,644,626 | 449,581 | 0.097 | 271 | 60.1% | 3.4% | 2.59% | 0.05% |
| Veritable Records of King Hyeonjong → Supplemented Veritable Records of King Hyeonjong | 9,296 | 10,506 | 1.130 | 1,030,951 | 1,382,412 | 1.341 | 3,774 | 84.1% | 94.7% | 2.32% | 0.46% |
| Veritable Records of King Sukjong → Supplement and Corrections to the Veritable Records of King Sukjong | 24,209 | 729 | 0.030 | 3,311,227 | 213,533 | 0.064 | 601 | 89.4% | 4.9% | 0.96% | 20.16% |
| Veritable Records of King Gyeongjong → Revised Veritable Records of King Gyeongjong | 2,744 | 431 | 0.157 | 354,711 | 119,405 | 0.337 | 309 | 99.0% | 23.9% | 1.49% | 1.39% |
| Daily Records of Gwanghaegun, second draft → Daily Records of Gwanghaegun, final draft | 22,121 | 18,805 | 0.850 | 2,739,912 | 2,244,156 | 0.819 | 4,920 | 99.9% | 96.9% | 0.94% | 0.00% |