Sillok Metrics
한국어
Other pages in this series (34)
Volume and density of the recordshare

Share of articles with a historian's comment

Share of articles that carry a historian's comment (史臣曰, XML postScript). The count of comments and their share of characters are shown too.

8.3%highest: Myeongjong
Key point

Shows which editions carry the historians' own judgments at all. Zero from Jeongjo onward means commentary can be cited only for Seonjo to Yeongjo.

Formula
Articles with ≥1 postScript / all articles
How to read it
First exceeds 2% under Seongjong and peaks at 3–8% under Jungjong, Myeongjong and Seonjo. From Jeongjo onward it is zero.
Caveats
Follows NIKH tagging; comments written as small-type notes may be untagged.
External check
Shown next to Cha Jang-seop's early-Joseon counts (one '史臣曰' = one comment). Two values on this site are kept apart: articles carrying a comment tag (Seongjong 658, Yeonsangun 40, Jungjong 1,213, Injong 50, Myeongjong 1,254) and the number of tags (665, 40, 1,346, 56, 1,455); the latter shares Cha's unit.
Reliability card
exactExact count — read straight from the source XML

Shown next to Cha Jang-seop's early-Joseon counts (one '史臣曰' = one comment). Two values on this site are kept apart: articles carrying a comment tag (Seongjong 658, Yeonsangun 40, Jungjong 1,213, Injong 50, Myeongjong 1,254) and the number of tags (665, 40, 1,346, 56, 1,455); the latter shares Cha's unit.

0.0%5.0%10.0%15.0%20.0%Veritable Records of King TaejoVeritable Records of King Taejo: 0.0%Veritable Records of King JeongjongVeritable Records of King Jeongjong: 0.2%Veritable Records of King TaejongVeritable Records of King Taejong: 0.0%Veritable Records of King SejongVeritable Records of King Sejong: 0.0%Veritable Records of King MunjongVeritable Records of King Munjong: 0.0%Veritable Records of King DanjongVeritable Records of King Danjong: 0.2%Veritable Records of King SejoVeritable Records of King Sejo: 0.1%Veritable Records of King YejongVeritable Records of King Yejong: 0.1%Veritable Records of King SeongjongVeritable Records of King Seongjong: 2.0%Daily Records of YeonsangunDaily Records of Yeonsangun: 0.3%Veritable Records of King JungjongVeritable Records of King Jungjong: 3.1%Veritable Records of King InjongVeritable Records of King Injong: 7.4%Veritable Records of King MyeongjongVeritable Records of King Myeongjong: 8.3%Veritable Records of King SeonjoVeritable Records of King Seonjo: 2.6%Revised Veritable Records of King SeonjoRevised Veritable Records of King Seonjo: 0.1%Daily Records of Gwanghaegun, second draftDaily Records of Gwanghaegun, second draft: 0.9%Daily Records of Gwanghaegun, final draftDaily Records of Gwanghaegun, final draft: 0.0%Veritable Records of King InjoVeritable Records of King Injo: 1.0%Veritable Records of King HyojongVeritable Records of King Hyojong: 0.2%Veritable Records of King HyeonjongVeritable Records of King Hyeonjong: 2.3%Supplemented Veritable Records of King HyeonjongSupplemented Veritable Records of King Hyeonjong: 0.5%Veritable Records of King SukjongVeritable Records of King Sukjong: 1.0%Supplement and Corrections to the Veritable Records of King SukjongSupplement and Corrections to the Veritable Records of King Sukjong: 20.2%Veritable Records of King GyeongjongVeritable Records of King Gyeongjong: 1.5%Revised Veritable Records of King GyeongjongRevised Veritable Records of King Gyeongjong: 1.4%Veritable Records of King YeongjoVeritable Records of King Yeongjo: 1.3%Veritable Records of King JeongjoVeritable Records of King Jeongjo: 0.0%Veritable Records of King SunjoVeritable Records of King Sunjo: 0.0%Veritable Records of King HeonjongVeritable Records of King Heonjong: 0.0%Veritable Records of King CheoljongVeritable Records of King Cheoljong: 0.0%Veritable Records of King GojongVeritable Records of King Gojong: 0.0%Veritable Records of King SunjongVeritable Records of King Sunjong: 0.0%Veritable Records of King Sunjong, appendixVeritable Records of King Sunjong, appendix: 0.0%
All 33 editions; muted color marks revised, supplemented, supplement-and-corrections and second-draft editions.
EditionArticlesDated articlesCharactersReign (months)Articles/yearCharacters/yearMedian lengthHistorians' commentsShare with historians' commentsEmpty months
Veritable Records of King Taejo2,3872,251193,6438134629,7672300.0%0
Veritable Records of King Jeongjong62662464,8612432533,7952510.2%0
Veritable Records of King Taejong10,33810,3361,061,57022257859,3404020.0%2
Veritable Records of King Sejong32,28130,9483,887,345391980123,1424000.0%0
Veritable Records of King Munjong2,6722,670399,503321,086162,4895900.0%5
Veritable Records of King Danjong2,5472,532372,73740805118,4856150.2%0
Veritable Records of King Sejo10,90110,8061,231,19916680791,96052130.1%1
Veritable Records of King Yejong1,5041,501236,144171,130177,8356720.1%0
Veritable Records of King Seongjong32,44432,4384,089,8393111,295163,219456652.0%0
Daily Records of Yeonsangun12,01012,0061,385,1011461,030118,78341400.3%0
Veritable Records of King Jungjong39,66039,6585,886,8594741,035153,614521,3463.1%0
Veritable Records of King Injong672667119,35181,149205,62372567.4%0
Veritable Records of King Myeongjong15,04515,0421,875,79527268585,373361,4558.3%0
Veritable Records of King Seonjo26,71626,6794,644,626503657114,452827172.6%65
Revised Veritable Records of King Seonjo1,8741,867449,5815034611,0788810.1%71
Daily Records of Gwanghaegun, second draft22,12122,1212,739,9121871,465181,423622110.9%0
Daily Records of Gwanghaegun, final draft18,80518,8052,244,1561871,245148,5976000.0%0
Veritable Records of King Injo16,04716,0412,218,99032561384,742611701.0%0
Veritable Records of King Hyojong5,4335,427924,57912554192,16642100.2%0
Veritable Records of King Hyeonjong9,2969,2911,030,95118961067,651442202.3%0
Supplemented Veritable Records of King Hyeonjong10,50610,5021,382,41218968990,71443480.5%0
Veritable Records of King Sukjong24,20924,2053,311,22756852872,246422331.0%0
Supplement and Corrections to the Veritable Records of King Sukjong729726213,533568164,66316814820.2%237
Veritable Records of King Gyeongjong2,7442,740354,7115464182,99539411.5%0
Revised Veritable Records of King Gyeongjong431431119,405579526,22510261.4%4
Veritable Records of King Yeongjo36,73236,7253,868,75863971375,074414831.3%0
Veritable Records of King Jeongjo17,68217,6703,344,617302726137,3355200.0%0
Veritable Records of King Sunjo15,53015,5201,437,46842545241,8811800.0%0
Veritable Records of King Heonjong3,9873,979186,53918227212,7661300.0%0
Veritable Records of King Cheoljong5,7725,764208,89918039814,4341300.0%0
Veritable Records of King Gojong27,94027,9392,749,11553564263,1903300.0%0
Veritable Records of King Sunjong1,3881,386111,3483844535,7373800.0%0
Veritable Records of King Sunjong, appendix3,4723,472135,7652161947,6032500.0%23

Next to prior figures

EditionTagged articles (this site)Tagged comments (this site)Cha, Table 2 (count of 史臣曰)
Veritable Records of King Jeongjong111
Veritable Records of King Sejo13135
Veritable Records of King Yejong222
Veritable Records of King Seongjong658665629
Daily Records of Yeonsangun404034
Veritable Records of King Jungjong1,2131,3461,261
Veritable Records of King Injong505655
Veritable Records of King Myeongjong1,2541,4551,439

Download CSV: a_editions.csv